The ability of humans to communicate with one another through the use of language is one of the most beneficial abilities. Both my partner and I had high expectations to communicate without using language, however we both agreed it was hard prior to the experiment. Being that I was not allowed to speak, I used expressions and body movements in order to get my point across. The hardest challenge about the first phase was finding the correct expression and/ or body language to correctly get my message across. With the absence of my language ability, it was hard to communicate. I am so reliable on language to communicate that It took some time to adjust to the fact that I was not using language, and figure out an alternative way to communicate. After using physical representations to get my message across, I began to realize that my partner also began to using physical body movements to figure out what I was portraying.
Regarding both parts one and two, I felt that my partner had a majority of control. Given that I was not able to use sound in the first part and my partner was, I was not in control of telling my partner what I was trying to say. I felt very out of control because I was not able to tell my partner what I would if I was able to speak; therefore it was hard to find the right body movements, expressions, and gestures to communicate with my partner. In the second part of the experiential assignment, I felt I had more control than in part one, however I was not able to use expressions, or tones in my voice in order to express my opinion of the topic. I still felt pressured to not use these aspects in language to communicate. This gave me less power in this experiment, but still more than the prior experiment.
If my partner and I represent two different cultures and spoke different languages, it would be harder to communicate given that we would not understand each other. When speaking the same language, the people in that population that are able to speak this language has an advantage to understand everything that one another is saying to each other. It would be harder to understand the concept of what this person is trying to say. I would also take longer to communicate with one another. In our community today, there are deaf people in which cannot communicate regularly with others who are not deaf. Although the deaf community has their own language, they are still excluded from many other non-deaf people today. I continuously see people trying to avoid deaf people and ignoring them in public places.
In the second part of the assignment, both my partner and I were able to speak; however, I was not able to use expressions or different ones in my voice. This was difficult because I was not able to express my opinion with my words.
This experiments emphasizes the benefit of language and ability to speak, hear, use physical movement, and expression to communicate. When speaking with expression and tone we are able to put meaning behind our words as well as making the words we speak have smaller and greater meaning. Body language also helps to interpret things; for example, how much these words mean to them.
The adaptive benefit to possessing the ability to read body language is that we are able to read others body language as well as interpret the meaning behind their language. We place meaning to words by adding body language, tone, expressions, etc. The blind community does not have the ability to view body language. People are quick to judge the blind community when seeing and, or taking to these people.
This experiment has made the benefit of language very clear. The language that is spoken and unspoken are both very important. I personally think that language is the most important aspects in life.
I think that you have brought up a good point that humans rely on both the symbolic and body language. Our body language gives people the context of the message. As a dancer we do not speak on stage and so we heavily rely on body language to tell a story. I found that only using symbolic language was difficult.
ReplyDeletePart A: Good opening description.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your conclusions regarding power and control, but this only pertained to the first experiment.
"If my partner and I represent two different cultures and spoke different languages, it would be harder to communicate given that we would not understand each other. "
But that wasn't the question. Which culture would have the advantage of communicating complex ideas within their own culture, so you headed down a rabbit hole on this one and didn't fully explore the issue.
Missing: What would the attitude be of the speaking to the non-speaking culture?
Good real-life example.
Part B: Your description is far too short for full credit here. This is often the most interesting experiment, particularly the response of the partner, and you don't discuss that at all. Expand. I can't make any connections from your description to your conclusions in the next two sections.
I don't disagree with your conclusions regarding the information we receive from body language, but you are only considering the situation where body language matches and supports the information you receive from spoken language. What does it tell you when the body language doesn't match the spoken language? Humans tend to use body language as a type of lie detector. If spoken words don't match with the body language, we are more inclined to believe the body language and doubt the words. Think about how being able to detect liars might help an individual's ability to survive and reproduce (which applies to the next section).
The section on the "adaptive benefit" is specifically asking how reading body language can help a person survive and reproduce. You don't make that connection here. Too general.
"The blind community does not have the ability to view body language. "
Yes, they have difficulty but they can still hear vocal intonations. You could also use those in the autism spectrum as an example.
You are missing an answer to the final question? Can you think of a situation where it would benefit you to avoid reading body language? When might body language of others mislead you and it would be better to ignore it? Do all cultures use the same system of body language? They all use different systems of spoken/written language, so why would we assume their body language isn't different? If you travel to another country, can you trust the information you get from their body language?